Indiana Car Dealers, Good or Not

We rated 370 car dealers in Indiana. 33 percent get a Buyers say yes and 24 percent a Mostly no. Around Indianapolis IN 34 percent of lots earn a yes, the best share in the state.

• 370rated dealers
• 123Buyers say yes
• 87Mostly no
• 2metro lists

Pick a Metro

• Indianapolis IN 325 rated, 34% yes
• Louisville KY 45 rated, 31% yes

Top Scoring Dealers in Indiana

• Indy Auto Man Used Cars Indianapolis

  Used car dealer · 4031 S East St, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 6,974 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 38 reviewers left one or two stars across 6,974 reviews.

  Reviewers praise easy process, kind staff, smooth process.

  Also listed on BBB, Yelp, Facebook, Carfax, Edmunds

  Call (317) 300-5002 Website Map

• DriveTime Used Cars

  Used car dealer · 3717 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 3,464 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 56 reviewers left one or two stars across 3,464 reviews.

  Reviewers praise easy process, smooth process.

  Call (317) 613-1280 Website Map

• DriveTime Used Cars

  Used car dealer · 1202 Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 3,232 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 41 reviewers left one or two stars across 3,232 reviews.

  Reviewers praise easy process, smooth process.

  Call (317) 554-0355 Website Map

• HyperCars

  Used car dealer · 1212 E Spring St, New Albany · Louisville KY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 1,813 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 38 reviewers left one or two stars across 1,813 reviews.

  Reviewers praise smooth process, quick process, no pressure sales.

  Also listed on Carfax, Kelley Blue Book

  Call (502) 653-1991 Website Map

• Cash Car Heroes

  Used car dealer · 3004 Stanley Ave, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.8 stars from 1,800 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 46 reviewers left one or two stars across 1,800 reviews.

  Reviewers praise easy process.

  Also listed on Facebook

  Call (317) 743-2660 Website Map

• Craig and Landreth Clarksville

  Used car dealer · 619 E Lewis and Clark Pkwy, Clarksville · Louisville KY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 1,020 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 44 reviewers left one or two stars across 1,020 reviews.

  Reviewers praise no pressure sales, fair pricing.

  Call (812) 280-8018 Website Map

• Indy Auto Finance

  Used car dealer · 5050 W 38th St, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 831 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 52 reviewers left one or two stars across 831 reviews.

  Reviewers praise easy process.

  Call (317) 474-6444 Website Map

• Carplex Indy West

  Used car dealer · 4910 W 38th St, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 827 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 52 reviewers left one or two stars across 827 reviews.

  Reviewers praise kind staff.

  Call (317) 347-8800 Website Map

• Tom Wood Lexus

  Lexus dealer · 4610 E 96th St, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes97 of 100

  4.8 stars from 5,324 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 25 reviewers left one or two stars across 5,324 reviews.

  Reviewers praise smooth process, no pressure sales.

  Call (463) 298-0787 Website Map

• Enterprise Car Sales

  Used car dealer · 1704 Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes97 of 100

  4.8 stars from 1,651 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 29 reviewers left one or two stars across 1,651 reviews.

  Reviewers praise kind staff, quick process, no pressure sales.

  Call (317) 377-5615 Website Map

• Dreyer & Reinbold MINI Cooper

  MINI dealer · 9333 Haver Way, Indianapolis · Indianapolis IN list

  Buyers say yes97 of 100

  4.8 stars from 1,156 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 30 reviewers left one or two stars across 1,156 reviews.

  Reviewers praise kind staff, easy process, no pressure sales.

  Call (317) 574-5511 Website Map

• Mike's Car Store

  Used car dealer · 8379 IN-64, Georgetown · Louisville KY list

  Buyers say yes97 of 100

  4.9 stars from 854 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 30 reviewers left one or two stars across 854 reviews.

  Reviewers praise kind staff, quick process, no pressure sales.

  Call (812) 940-6453 Website Map